A fun twist on the chosen one narrative and a wonderful rife on the Harry Potter novels. Carry On also has the distinct feel of fan fiction and some of the tropes associated with fan creations. The feeling of fan fiction makes the novel even more fun and allows for all traditional aspects of chosen one stories to be flipped on their heads. The way the book also deals with gay characters is rather refreshing considering the whitewashing and straight cis relationships the genre thrives on.
Grade: A /
Obie / Nov 29, 2015
Loved, loved, loved this book. After reading Fangirl, I couldn't wait for this book to be released. I was hooked almost from the beginning, and I wish there was more to read. For me it was one of those books that you read and realize your face hurts from smiling. Certainly there are nods and similarities to other works, but enough originality to keep my interest. Another winner from Rainbow Rowell!
Grade: A /
StephanieL / Jan 26, 2016
I was not sure about this book because when I read FanGirl the parts of Carry On were my least favorite. I'm not opposed to fan fiction, but I've never gotten into it. I didn't think I would like this. But come on. This is Rainbow Rowell. She could make a toaster manual fascinating. I loved this book and really found myself wishing there was more. I couldn't put it down. :)
The beginning was a bit slow and shallow, and the ghost POV's sometimes missed their mark, but once Baz showed up I was hooked - on both the characters' relationships and the mystery. Sign me up as a Baz/Simon fangirl asap. Somehow this fantasy world pays homage to other magical stories without being derivative or boring. Also the ending of this book is how I wish Harry Potter ended. Highly recommend, even if you haven't read Fangirl. Can't wait to read it again!
In her author note at the end of the novel, Rowell claims this is a tale inspired by hundreds of chosen one stories. But it's not. Her characters, settings, and plot all mimic the immortal Rowling's, outfitted with fun twists and delightful levity. (The spell system is a highlight for sure.) Despite its origin, the text doesn't read like fanfiction. The queer romantic angst delivers some really great scenes. As for the mystery elements? They lack intrigue and make for a clumsy conclusion.
Come check out ScreenDigits, our companion site for tracking the movies and shows you watch!
/ Jan 16, 2018
/ Jul 19, 2018